Chiraan Uvach
A Sermon on Indian Tradition

DANCE OF DEMOCRACY

Democracy in INDIA is about rule by Minority

  • less than 50% vote
  • of this multiparty party system ensures, of that 50% ,one who has secured maojority rules .
  • IN multiparty system , percentage of votes polled by th candidate may not be even 20% of electorate .
  • Yet he assumes power .
  • Lets see an example
    • a city has population of  20 lakhs
    • four candidates compete
    • 45% vote
    • ie only 9 lakhs vote
    • Candidate A gets 4 lakhs vote
    • candidate B gets 4.5 lakhs
    • C gets 30000
    • rest by D
  • B is elected .
  • B actually has backing of only 20%
  • What about other 20% , cant they have any representation of their needs ,
    • NO , we do not have anything of that
    • Though B has won only by a 2 % margin , an equivalent size of electoral votes is of no importance atleast for next 5 years
    • A having gained such a sizeable backing is not considered
    • HAD there been no D , then perhaps A would have got more lead than B
    • This is of no significance in our dance .
    • HAd there been a E then perhaps B would have lost
    • This is also not considered .
  • So a election is a toss , you can win it or lose it .
  • There is nothing as mandate here . its pure LUCK .
  • There could as well had been an elephant with a pitcher that would declare a winner . Still the result would be as predictable .
    • Consider this :
    • four cities P1 P2 P3 P4 P5
    • consider two Parties A and B
    • in P1 ,A gets 4 LAKHS VOTES B gets 5 lakhs
    • P2 – A gets  2 lakhs B gets 1 lakh
    • P3   A gets  5.5 lakhs b gets 6 lakhs
    • P4   A gets 4 lakhs  B gets 2 lakhs
    • P5 neither A wins 1 lakh or B 0.5 lakh but  C wins .
  • Total in five cities  A has won 2 seats B has won 2 seats C 1
  • A has polled 16.5 lakhs votes
  • B has 14.5 lakhs
  • C joins B and forms GOVT .
  • Look A has more votes than B and C put together  , Yet It cannot rule .
  • Where is the rule of MAJORITY !!!!!
  • What about sizeable 7 lakhs which has no representation of their wants needs and ideas .
  • Is it not sizeable .
  • That means cant we have representation  according to  votes polled . also along with the winner and loser .
  • After all if every VOte has to count then it has also to be represented as well .
  • WHen there is no representation , and LUCK rules the ROOST , then why not accept KINGSHIP as fate . or why go at all to VOTE in anticipation that you may find few more like minded people and perhaps make a GOVT .
  • Truly when you dont have RAJYOGA , You may not win a majority also perhaps.

krishnarpana .

2 Responses to “DANCE OF DEMOCRACY”

  1. बहुत खूब…
    लोकतंत्र नामरूपी मज़ाक का अच्छा चिट्ठा खोला है….

    और फिर भी हम हैं कि भ्रमों में हैं…..

    • Dhanyavad ,
      agar second pref votes gine jayenge toh bahuton ki rajneeti se chutti ho jayegi . Hamare jiteji yeh shayad mumkin na hon , tab tak ke liye gantantra aur Prajatantra gajatantra ke barabar hi hai . hathi jiske gale me har dale wohi RAJA .


Leave a Reply